# SDD ledger — plan: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-07-27-lanes-pipeline.md

Base commit: 8e41e80 (branch feat/lanes-pipeline)

Task 1: review — spec MET, quality SOUND. 1 Important, 1 Minor.
Task 1: ruled — Important (.gitignore `data/` -> `/data/`) does NOT enter fix loop. Plan's Global Constraints say "Preserve existing behavior. Additive schema only"; a gitignore anchor changes no behavior, and the reviewer's "purely additive" alternative edits the same file AND cannot work alone (git cannot re-include a path under an excluded directory without also negating the parent). `/data/` is the correct minimal fix. Stands.
Task 1: minor (deferred): lanes-lib.test.js test title says "amber" where it means "without evidence" (wording inherited from the plan).
Task 1: complete (commits 8e41e80..8b9e477, review clean after ruling)

Task 2: review — spec MET except one deviation; all 5 load-bearing behaviors verified correct. 1 Important, 1 Minor.
Task 2: ruled — Important (lane SQL prepared inline in lanes.js instead of added to db.js `stmts`) does NOT enter fix loop: the plan contradicted itself (File Structure said "stmts entries", the Task 2 code block and its Interfaces line "Owns all SQL for lanes" say inline). The code block is authoritative; the stale File Structure line has been corrected in the plan so later reviews do not re-raise it.
Task 2: minor (deferred): lanes-lib.test.js @file comment still says it only covers pipelines.js.
Task 2: complete (commits 8b9e477..f29d904, review clean after ruling)

Task 3: review — spec MET; 1 "Critical" (WS payload asymmetry) ruled plan-mandated, 3 Important, 3 Minor.
Task 3: ruled — delete broadcasting `{removed: id}` instead of `{lane}` is deliberate and consumed by Task 7's Lanes.tsx; the plan's Produces bullet was stale prose and has been corrected. Not a defect.
Task 3: ruled — per-lane `SELECT MAX(created_at)` stands: events(session_id) is indexed and lanes number in the dozens (one per worktree), not thousands.
Task 3: ruled — broadcast-before-response stands: `broadcast()` in server/websocket.js is already defensive.
Task 3: minor (deferred): double payload() call per mutation (broadcastLane re-reads the lane); lanes-api.test.js tests share state via an outer laneId.
Task 3: fix round 1/5 (2 addressed, 0 open — 409 now branches on SQLITE_CONSTRAINT_UNIQUE with message fallback; new WS test asserts lane_update on create and delete; commits 8e76c90..76c6f26)
Task 3: complete (commits a69b3d8..76c6f26, review clean)

Task 4: review — spec FAIL (1 Critical: needs_action cleared by any session), 2 Important, 1 Minor.
Task 4: ruled — the Critical was real. The plan's own contract said "cleared on the next non-Notification hook for that lane"; amended to "from the session currently bound to that lane, evaluated before rebinding" so two agents sharing one worktree cannot cancel each other's "needs you".
Task 4: fix round 1/5 (3 addressed, 0 open — clear now gated on the pre-existing lane.session_id; cross-session + default-message tests added, verified to fail against the buggy code; per-hook lane-scan ceiling documented, no cache; commits 83aa655..3f7121d)
Task 4: complete (commits 76c6f26..3f7121d, review clean) — 780 server tests pass

Task 5: first attempt reported DONE_WITH_CONCERNS claiming the sandbox blocks loopback — WRONG, and nothing was committed (pre-commit test gate held). Real cause: the plan's own test harness used blocking spawnSync while the test HTTP server ran in the same process, so the event loop stalled and the CLI child's request was never served. Verified loopback works between processes (detached node server + curl + separate node fetch, all exit 0). Plan's code block corrected to async spawn.
Task 5: review — spec PASS, 2 Important (ccam lanes add untested; temp DB leaked), 3 Minor.
Task 5: fix round 1/5 (2 addressed, 1 open — lanes-add test added, health poll replaced the 100ms sleep, DB cleanup added but not exception-safe; commits 19dd31b..3deb420)
Task 5: fix round 2/5 (1 addressed, 0 open — after() teardown wrapped in try/finally; commit 35138b4; verified inline)
Task 5: complete (commits 3f7121d..35138b4, review clean) — 783 server tests pass. `ccam lanes add` was an authorised addition so the CLI's empty-state hint names a command that exists.

Task 6: review — spec MET; security verified adversarially (cross-origin POST to /:id/start returns 403; prompt travels via stdin, model/effort/resumeSessionId are separate argv with no shell; /:id/stage not captured by /:id/:action; unknown action rejected before any lookup or mutation). 1 Important, 2 Minor.
Task 6: fix round 1/5 (2 addressed, 0 open — message now consults getRun and returns 409 for a recorded-but-dead run instead of 500; unknown-action test asserts stage/status unchanged; new 409 test; commits f225fe8..b3f9e2f)
Task 6: minor (deferred): lane.cwd is not re-validated at action time — a vanished directory fails cleanly at spawn.
Task 6: complete (commits 35138b4..b3f9e2f, review clean) — 788 server tests pass

Task 7: review — 4 Critical, 2 Important, 2 Minor. Three of the Criticals were the PLAN's fault (it mandated wrapping LaneCard in a <button>, an unconfirmed remove, and hardcoded English strings). Review was right; plan was wrong.
Task 7: fix round 1/5 (7 addressed, 0 open — selection is now a keyboard-operable role="button" div with stopPropagation on actions; remove goes through the existing ConfirmModal; every string i18n'd with real zh/vi/ko translations; Lanes case added to screens.snapshot.test.tsx; unknown-lane lane_update refetches so counters stay server-truthful; amber-vs-green test now asserts the colour tokens; start's empty-prompt behaviour documented in a tooltip; commits f29f597..a05065d)
Task 7: minor (deferred): the Lanes screen snapshot captures the empty state only — a populated card + pipeline map is not snapshotted.
Task 7: minor (deferred): the card cannot send a prompt — driving a lane from the UI needs a prompt/message input; today `start` opens a promptless conversation run and `message` has no input field. Follow-up feature, not a defect.
Task 7: complete (commits b3f9e2f..a05065d, review clean) — verified by controller: 279/279 client tests, `npm run build` clean

Task 8: review — every documented command/flag/env var/endpoint/state-rule fact-checked against the shipped code and correct, EXCEPT one Critical: docs advertised `ccam lanes add --pipeline <id>` which the CLI never parsed.
Task 8: ruled — fix the CODE, not the docs: a pipeline template you cannot select from the CLI is a template nobody uses, and the server already accepted the field. Authorised a scoped code change inside the docs task.
Task 8: fix round 1/5 (1 addressed, 0 open — --pipeline parsed and forwarded only when provided, usage string updated, two tests via a DASHBOARD_PIPELINES_DIR fixture with cleanup, docs parenthetical corrected; commits 6cca59c..3b196ef)
Task 8: minor (deferred): README VN/CN/KO mirrors are now behind the English README; the repo's update-project-docs convention expects them synced.
Task 8: complete (commits a05065d..3b196ef, review clean) — 790 server tests pass

Final whole-branch review (Opus): READY — no Critical/Important/Minor findings. Cross-cutting types, CLI-vs-server cwd resolution, WS payload branches, migration safety on an existing DB, the same-origin guard on the spawning routes, and both confirmation gates all verified. All 8 deferred/parked items triaged acceptable-to-defer, none load-bearing.
Controller end-to-end smoke test (real server, real CLI, real hook POSTs) — lane created, `ccam stage plan --evidence` then `ccam stage review` reported: node states came back intake=passed-no-evidence, plan=done, implement/tests=passed-no-evidence, review=current, rest=pending; progress 57%; stage_seconds live; `ccam lanes` table and counters correct; a Notification hook bound the lane and a later hook from the newly-bound session cleared needs_action exactly as the amended contract specifies.
Side effect found and REVERTED: starting the fork's server auto-configured Claude Code hooks in ~/.claude/settings.json (8 entries pointing at this fork). Removed surgically; the pre-existing `rtk hook claude` PreToolUse entry was left untouched. Polluted copy kept at /tmp/settings.before-ccam-cleanup.json.
